Despite significant scholarly attention, the problem of evil remains largely unresolved. This research explores the philosophical concepts of Theodicy, on the one hand, and Deus Mortuus (a ‘Dead God’) and Deus Absconditus (a ‘Hidden God’), often linked to nihilism and existential crises, as potential therapeutic frameworks for individuals grappling with the suffering of injustice. By examining how these concepts can paradoxically offer solace to those experiencing profound pain, this study bridges the gap to develop a mollifying approach that acknowledges the depth of human suffering while providing a framework for finding meaning and resilience. Focusing on individuals experiencing morally unjust suffering, this research investigates the therapeutic applications of Deus Mortuus and Deus Absconditus as pathways toward healing and reconciliation. Employing a philosophical methodology, this study contributes to a more holistic approach to comfort, offering a new paradigm for understanding and addressing human suffering and the potential efficacy of these philosophical concepts in mitigating psychological distress. Significantly, this study displays the limitations of traditional theodicies, and the inadequate or even harmful nature of it for individuals struggling with suffering. Consequently, it provides alternative frameworks in Deus Mortuus (the death of God) and Deus Absconditu (the hidden God) presenting an innovative solution to the problem of evil. This research concludes that Deus Mortuus and Deus Absconditu, while seemingly nihilistic, offer alternative frameworks for addressing the problem of evil having challenged traditional theodicies.